Regulatory Uncertainty in the US: Pushing Energy Investment Abroad

by Jonathan Bass

Regulatory uncertainty in the United States is a growing concern for investors in the energy sector, mirroring trends across industries (Baldwin, 2015). This blog post explores how fluctuating US regulations are driving investment towards more stable markets, impacting the global energy landscape.

The Impact of US Regulatory Uncertainty on Energy Investment

  • Policy Shifts and Delays: Frequent changes in environmental regulations, project approval processes, and future policy ambiguity make long-term investment viability difficult to predict (Helm, 2020). For example, the Biden administration's pause on new oil and gas leases exemplifies this uncertainty, aligning with research on policy uncertainty discouraging investment (Malmendier & Ulrich, 2004). In the US it is the Carrot and not the Stick.

  • Inconsistent Fossil Fuel Support: The US exhibits a "stop-go" approach to fossil fuels, with administrations promoting or restricting production. This inconsistency deters long-term investment, as companies lack a stable regulatory environment, similar to historical contexts where such policies hindered investment (Stavins & Sweeney, 2002).

The Rise of Stable Investment Destinations in the Global Energy Market

Keywords: Stable Energy Investment, Renewables Investment, Emerging Energy Markets

As the US grapples with regulatory uncertainty, other countries are attracting energy investment:

  • Europe's Clear and Consistent Policies: Europe, with its commitment to the Paris Agreement and clear renewable energy policies, has become an attractive destination (Berk et al., 2023). Countries like Germany and Denmark offer robust frameworks for renewable projects, ensuring long-term support for investors (Fattouh et al., 2017).

  • The Middle East's Strategic Investments: The Middle East, particularly Qatar and the UAE, are proactively diversifying their energy portfolios and offering investment incentives. QatarEnergy's stable regulatory environment and strategic direction make it a lucrative option (Cavusgil et al., 2004).

  • Asia's Booming Energy Markets: India's rapidly expanding energy infrastructure, backed by significant government support, presents a promising (on paper) investment environment for investors seeking growth (KPMG, 2023).

Case Studies: Stability Breeds Investment

Keywords: QatarEnergy Investment, European Green Energy Investment

  • QatarEnergy: This company has seen increased investment due to its stable regulatory environment and clear energy strategies, highlighting the importance of a long-term vision for investors (CNBC, 2023).

  • European Green Energy Projects: The EU's predictable regulatory framework for green energy projects has attracted significant investment, demonstrating the positive impact of clear regulations on renewables investment (Pohl et al., 2017).

Conclusion: The Need for US Regulatory Stability

The US's regulatory uncertainty is a critical factor driving energy investment abroad. The rules of the game are not clear, you cannot make business decisions only on subsidises. As the global energy market evolves, countries offering stable and supportive frameworks are becoming more attractive. To retain its competitive edge, the US must address these inconsistencies and foster a long-term investment environment in the energy sector.

References

  • Baldwin, R. (2015). The globotics imperative: How to succeed in a world where everything is connected. PublicAffairs.
  • Berk, M., Frondel, M., & Kammer, D. (2023). The European Green Deal and its impact on global energy markets. DIW Berlin Discussion Papers, (1850).
  • Cavusgil, S. T., Cavusgil, D. H., & Yeniaras, R. (2004). The influence of social capital on entrepreneurs' access to financial resources in the Turkish context. Journal of Business Venturing, 19(5), 617-640.
  • CNBC. (2023, April 11). QatarEnergy inks massive LNG deal with China. https://www.cnbc.com/video/2023/12/14/global-demand-for-lng-is-off-the-charts-cheniere-energy-ceo.html
  • Fattouh, B., El-Khazali, R., & Al-Saggaf, A. (2017). Renewable energy support policies: Design considerations and lessons learned from the MENA region. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 74, 823-835.
  • Helm, D. (2020). Uncertainty and climate change. The Journal of
Back to Argent LNG Blog